19 Best Eyeliners for Waterline Review in 2023 (Updated Version)

Do you want the best eyeliners for waterline? If yes, then relax and digest this article as it is meant for you.

Often, you may want to make your eyes look bigger or smoky during makeup, and tighlining (applying your eyeliner along the waterline of your lashes) is perhaps the best way to get the job done.

But the process isn’t as easy as it sounds, because the waterline is a thin, wet and sensitive area. As such, you can not afford to be careless, rather you need an eyeliner that comes with a highly pigmented formula and doesn’t smudge.

However, because there are so many brands of eyeliner in the market today, finding one that will be an excellent choice can be hard. Luckily, we’ve done the hard part for you, by compiling details of some of the best eyeliners for your waterline.

The purpose of this review is to provide you with adequate information about the top 19 best eyeliners for waterline based on their unique features and functions. Enjoy your read!

1. Urban Decay 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil

The 24/7 Waterline Eye Pencil by Urban Decay stand at the frontline of the best eyeliners for the waterline in the beauty industry today.

This is because it has a rich waterproof formula that is created with moisturizing ingredients.  It is available in classic black, navy, brown, and nude.

The formula sets within less than 30 seconds if you wish to give it a little blending. After setting, the eyeliner offers a multi-coloured, rainbow finish and stays in place all day long.

Pros

• The formula has a unique velvety and creamy texture that can be blended easily.
• The formula glides on smoothly without pulling or irritating your waterline.
• It is safe for super-sensitive waterlines, as it is free of parabens, sulfates, and phthalates.

Cons

• It is slightly expensive.
• It does not self-sharpen.

If you did like to own one of these, click below.

2. Milani Stay Put Waterproof Eyeliner

This eyeliner is considered to be one of the best eyeliners for the waterline, as its highly pigmented gel-formula is ideal for tightlining and can make your eyes look pop and intensified within seconds.

Its creamy texture makes it great for creating an ideal smoky eye vibe that lasts all day long. Without a doubt, this eyeliner is designed to add drama, intensity, and intrigue to your daily looks.

Pros

• It is very affordable.
• This waterproof gel pencil makes blending very easy and delivers a smudge-free finish.
• It is transfer-resistant and cruelty-free.
• The eyeliner comes in 5 attractive shades.

READ ALSO: Signature Eyelash Curler Review

Cons

• The softness of eyeliner makes it very easy to break off during sharpening.

Want more information on the Milani Stay Put Waterproof Eyeliner? Click below.

3. Essence Extreme Lasting Eye Pencil

If you’re looking for an eyeliner that is extremely cheap but still offers the best results, the Essence Extreme Lasting Eye Pencil is one of the best eyeliners for the waterline, which can be an excellent fit for your needs.

The smooth texture makes it easier to apply, as the formula goes right onto lids.

The Essence Extreme Lasting Eye Pencil is available in six shades of exceptional hues, including; Black Midnight Sky, a  Rockin’ Taupe, a deep blue, and Nightime in the Jungle, a rich brown.

Pros

• True to its name, this highly affordable eyeliner by essence is long-lasting.
• It has an impressive waterproof and high smudge-proof staying power.
• The formula comes with a packed-in pigment that offers an impressive colour finish.

Cons

• It requires sharpening.
• The tip breaks off easily if not properly.

If you like the Essence Extreme Lasting Eye Pencil, click below.

4. Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner

If black is not your favourite colour when it comes to your waterline, then this eyeliner may just be what you’re looking for.

The Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner is one of the best eyeliners for waterline when it comes to colour.

It is literally like choosing from a box of crayons. An additional bonus is that they all come in different awesome finishes, including satin, sparkly shimmer, and matte.

Pros

• It offers a wide variety of fun colour choices, like teal, peach, orchid, hot pink, etc.
• This gel eyeliner comes with an easy vitamin E–enriched glide.
• Be it for parties, work, or just your everyday looks, this beloved eyeliner is well-equipped for on-the-go and last-minute applications.

READ ALSO: Revitalash Double-Ended Volume Set Review

Cons

• The tip of the eyeliner is very thin so you must very careful when sharpening. It can break off easily if otherwise.

If you’re interested in purchasing this colour eyeliner, click below

5. Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Eye Pencil

If you love tightlining your upper waterline to create that “invisible eyeliner” look, then this eyeliner is a convenient way to satisfy your needs.

The huge amount of awards that the eyeliner has had in its name, evidently makes it one of the best eyeliners for the waterline.

The Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Eye Pencil is created with an incredibly rich formula that comes in a more convenient pencil form with an extra-pointy tip.

• The formula is highly pigmented with intense colour pay-off
• It has a reliable staying power, with the ability to stay put for over 12 hours.
• The extra-pointy tip of the pencil makes it easier to slide against the waterline without skipping on your lashes.
• It does not sting

Cons

• The formula may not come off with a regular makeup wipe. Thus, you have to use specifically use an eye makeup remover.

If you fancy a pack of the Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Eye Pencil, click below

6. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eye Liner Pencil

This incredibly pigmented eyeliner is one of the best eyeliners for the waterline. With the creamy texture of its formula, you can easily line your eyes in white and make it look more awake and intensified.

This particular shade of eyeliner pencil is greatly praised by enthusiastic reviewers, for being smudge-proof.

Pros

• The formula is incredibly pigmented
• This eyeliner comes in the form of a mechanical pencil that needs no sharpening.

READ ALSO: RevitaLash Deluxe Lash Kit (An In-depth Review)

Cons

• It is not water-resistant.
• If you have watery eyes, you may have to reapply the eyeliner very often

If you like the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eye Liner Pencil enough to purchase it, click below

7. Shiseido Kajal Ink Artist Shadow, Liner, Pencil

This eyeliner is one of the best eyeliners for waterline when it comes to multitasking during makeup. This is because it can serve as an eyeliner, kajal, eyeshadow, and brow filler.

With the graduated point and built-in smudger that this multitasking eyeliner comes with, you can easily create a stunning smoky or soft eye look that can last for 12 hours. The 4 in 1 eyeliner comes in eight shades, including; black, teal,  pink, and hunter green.

Pros

• It is one of the best easy to use multitasking eyeliner.
• It comes with a packed-in pigment that goes on seamlessly.
• This Shiseido product features a tear-proof formula that is crucial for the inner rim of your waterline.

Cons

• The built-in detachable sharpener is not very great at making a sharp point
• The lines the eyeliner create are not as crisp as it would be if it was a liquid eyeliner.

If you want to own of these, click below

8. Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner

If you constantly struggle with having to apply and re-apply your eyeliner several times, because the formula keeps pulling or tugging, then the Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner may be your best replacement. In terms of being waterproof, this eyeliner is one of the best eyeliners for the waterline.

The formula of this waterproof eyeliner is made with antioxidant vitamins C and E, volatile silicones, modern wax oil, etc. The amazing pigment that this eyeliner features, offers extra moisture and bold colours on your eyelids.

It also comes in 14 different shades, ranging from an array of blacks to exceptional hues like amethyst, olive, and jade. With a pack of this product in your possession, you can use a different colour on your waterline every day for two weeks.

Pros

• The unique combination of its ingredients makes the eyeliner long-lasting and comfortable for all-day wear.
• It comes in a mechanical pencil form, thus you don’t have to worry about sharpening.

READ ALSO: VLCC Anti Tan Single Facial Review

Cons

• It may not be accommodating for extremely sensitive eyes.

Like the Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner? Click below

9. Pat McGrath Permagel Ultra Eye Pencil

In terms of intensity, the Pat McGrath Permagel Ultra Eye Pencil is one of the best eyeliners for the waterline. With just a simple swipe, this gel pencil offers you much colour.

As such, you can create a striking eye look with just one go-around of the eyeliner formula. Within minutes, you can get a marvelling velvety look.

The Pat McGrath Permagel Ultra Eye Pencil is available in five different shades; some with a matte finish and others with a shimmer finish.

Pros

• The incredibly pigmented eyeliner is enriched with silicone which glides on smoothly and precisely.
• It gives you the chance to freestyle and does a little smudging before it sets.

Cons

• It is pretty costly for a pencil eyeliner.
• The formula tends to smudge when used to tightline on the lower lash line.

Interested in purchasing this best eyeliner for waterline? Click below

10. NARS Larger Than Life Long-Wear Eyeliner

NARS makeup products are usually crowd favorites and the Larger Than Life Long-Wear Eyeliner is not any different, for it can quickly give your waterline a whole new makeover with less irritation to the area.

The eyeliner pencil has a precise tip which makes it extra easy for tightening your water.

The eyeliner is available in 6 shades, each named after the most famous streets in the world, including Via Appia, a copper brown, and Rue Saint-Honor, a deep royal blue.

Pros

• This highly pigmented eyeliner also delivers intense color to your waterline.
• It has reliable staying power that ensures that you look fresh all day and night.
• The pencil also comes with a retractable applicator and a built-in sharpener.

READ ALSO: Thickening shampoo (A Detailed Review)

Cons

• The eyeliner is slightly expensive.

To get more information, click below

11. Charlotte Tilbury Rock N Kohl Eyeliner Pencil

The Rock N Kohl Eyeliner Pencil by Charlotte Tilbury is one of the best eyeliners for the waterline, especially when it comes to smoky eye looks.

This kohl eyeliner has a highly pigmented formula that offers the perfect finishing touch to your eyes by intensifying and pulling all your shadow, liner, and blending efforts to create an exceptional and long-lasting look.

With this eyeliner, you won’t even feel that you’ve anything ton your eyes until when you may want to take off.

Pros

• The formula has an extra creamy and almost silky texture.
• It is so lightweight that it automatically melts into your waterline.
• It is very easy to apply

Cons

• This eyeliner pencil requires sharpening before every use. This may lead to product wastage.

If you fancy a pack of the Charlotte Tilbury Rock N Kohl Eyeliner Pencil, click below

12. BareMinerals Round the Clock Intense Cream-Glide Eyeliner

Despite their claims while advertising, many conventional eyeliners don’t build well, as a result, you may have to deal with a big chunk of the formulas falling into your eyeballs.

Well, the BareMinerals Round the Clock Intense Cream-Glide Eyeliner is a game-changer and undoubtedly one of the best eyeliners for the waterline.

With the BareMinerals Round the Clock Intense Cream-Glide Eyeliner, you can easily create looks that range from subtle to fancy.

Pros

• It is specially designed with a buildable formula that is perfect for the waterline and tightlining.
• The eyeliner also glides on easily and stays put for a long time.

READ ALSO: Revitalash Volume Enhancing Foam Review

Cons

• The formula is not easy to take off
• The wooden part of the pencil may split from constant sharpening

Like the BareMinerals Round the Clock Intense Cream-Glide Eyeliner? Click below

13. Vasanti Cosmetics Hazel Brown Kajal Waterline Eyeliner Pencil

For those who are in search of an eyeliner that can give their eyes a subtle and naturally radiant look, this Hazel Brown Kajal Waterline Eyeliner Pencil by Vasanti Cosmetics is just what you need!

With just a single stroke on the lower lash line, you can give your eyes a subtle but intensified look.

The formula is made with no harsh chemicals such as parabens. This cruelty-free pencil is also dermatologist and ophthalmologist-tested.

Pros

• Its smooth and creamy formula ensures a non-messy application
• The eyeliner is also safe for sensitive eyes and contact wearers,
• Tightlining with this eyeliner is very easy and with a lesser irritation

Cons

• As a non-retractable eyeliner pencil, it could easily get damaged if it is over-twisted

Want more information on the Vasanti Cosmetics Hazel Brown Kajal Waterline Eyeliner Pencil, click below

14. Jillian Dempsey Natural Khôl Eyeliner

This naturally formulated kohl pencil, created by celebrity makeup artist, Jillian Dempsey, is arguably one of the best eyeliners for the waterline. It is better than a lot of conventional ones.

Its formula is infused with natural ingredients like organic jojoba oil, organic shea butter, sunflower seed oil, and avocado oil. This unique combination makes it easy for the formula to be applied without tugging.

Pros

• It is naturally formulated with rich organic ingredients.
• The waterproof eyeliner comes with a built-in smudger in case you need to smudge at the lash line and create a softer look.
• This kohl pencil is made without parabens, sulfates, petrochemicals, and synthetic fragrances or dyes.

Cons

• The eyeliner may not as long-lasting as you want.

If you’re interested in purchasing Jillian Dempsey Natural Khôl Eyeliner, click below

15. Laura Mercier Tightline Cake Eye Liner

If you are a loyal user of the old-school “cake” formula eyeliner, then this eyeliner may be your best friend.

While many other eyeliners for waterline comes in a pencil format, the Laura Mercier Tightline Cake Eye Liner comes in the form of an ultra-pigmented eye shadow with a drier.

To apply this eyeliner, you just simply dip a flat eyeliner brush into the compact; then gently press the brush onto the roots of your lower lash-line, while going back-and-forth slowly.

Pros

• The cake-like formula of the product makes it the one of most smudge-proof eyeliners.
• It has more intense features

Cons

• Using this eyeliner and getting outstanding results, may require some level of expertise

If you did like to own one of these, click below

16. Tarte Fake Awake Eyeliner

Wanting your eye to look natural but in a bigger, better, and more awake version is a desire that can easily be satisfied with the use of the Tarte Fake Awake Eyeliner.

After pulling an all-nighter or when having a hangover, the eyes get all red and drowsy. This eyeliner can make all these redness magically disappear.

You can give your eyes a total makeover when you use this to highlight the inner corner of your eyes and just underneath the brow bone. The eyeliner comes in one unique color; waterline flesh color.

Pros

• The eyeliner features a gentle, aloe-infused formula that instantly neutralizes any redness when applied to the waterline.

Cons

• Your choice of color with this eyeliner is highly limited as it does not have any other color except waterline flesh color.

If you’re interested in purchasing this eyeliner, then click below

17. Rimmel Ultimate Kohl Kajal

As a beginner to the whole applying eyeliner on your waterline game, the Rimmel Ultimate Kohl Kajal is the best eyeliner to get you started.

The eyeliner comes in a wide tube with a wide pointy tip.

Pros

• The design of the eyeliner makes it easy for you to have a good, sturdy grip when holding it
• The pointy tip enables easy and precise application of the formula on the waterline
• It is waterproof

Cons

• The formula is a little bit tougher to apply

Want more information about the Rimmel Ultimate Kohl Kajal, click below

18. Sleek Makeup Intense Waterliner

This eyeliner can easily be considered as one of the best eyeliners for waterline because of how intense and versatile it is.

You can apply the formula over your eyelids and simply blend it out to create a soft, smokey-eye, or fierce look.

Pros

• The sharp tip of the eyeliner makes it convenient for you to add definition and intensity to your eyelids.
• It is smudge-proof.
• It is safe to be applied directly on the upper and lower waterline without irritation.

Cons

• The pigmentation is not as intense as you may think
• It is not waterproof.

If you want to have one of this eyeliner for yourself or your loved ones, click below

19. MAC Kajal Crayon

One of the best eyeliners for the waterline, that has successfully impressed beauty gurus all over the world is the sleek and chic Kajal Crayon by MAC.

This chunky kajal crayon has a wide shape that makes it easier for you to grip, hold, and control it during usage. This eyeliner pencil also comes with a precision tip that helps you to tight line your waterline like an expert.

Pros

• The formula has a melting quality that blends easily and dries quickly.
• It offers a smudge-free finish.

Cons

• It is slightly expensive.

If you want more information about the M.A.C Kajal Crayon, click below

Conclusion

The waterline of the eyes is a very sensitive area that deserves only the best reliable eyeliners. The above eyeliners are your best options when it comes to making your eyes look bigger, better, and more awake with little or no irritation at all. The additional bonus is that most of these unique eyeliners are affordable.

We hope that with all of the details that we have provided in this review, you can now confidently a great choice of the best eyeliner for your waterline.

We would like to hear from you about these eyeliners for waterline – which one do you think is the best for your waterline and your overall beauty looks among the ones listed? Please endeavour to leave your comments below.